Carboxylesterases containing the sequence motif GGGX catalyze hydrolysis of esters of chiral tertiary alcohols, albeit at only low to moderate enantioselectivity towards three model substrates (linalyl acetate, methyl-1-pentin-1-yl acetate, 2-phenyl-3-butin-2-yl acetate). In order to understand the molecular mechanism of enantiorecognition and to improve enantioselectivity towards this interesting substrate class, the interaction of both enantiomers with the substrate binding sites of acetylcholinesterases and p-nitrobenzyl esterase from Bacillus subtilis was modeled and correlated to experimental enantioselectivity. For all substrate-enzyme pairs, enantiopreference and ranking by enantioselectivity could be predicted by the model. In p-nitrobenzyl esterase, one of the key residues in determining enantioselectivity was G105: exchange of this residue by alanine led to a six-fold increase of enantioselectivity (E=19) towards 2-phenyl-3-butin-2-yl acetate. However, the effect of this mutation is personalized: towards the substrate linalyl acetate, the same mutant had a reversed enantiopreference. Thus, depending on the substrate structure, the same mutant had either increased enantioselectivity or opposite enantiopreference compared to wild type enzyme.
